Managing experts when you’re not one yourself? Here’s how to ditch the imposter feelings and actually become the leader your team needs.
The moment I realised I was in trouble…
Picture this: I’ve just landed my first senior insight manager role, feeling pretty pleased with myself. First team meeting rolls around, and my analysts start throwing around terms about market data and v-look ups like it’s basic conversation. Meanwhile, I’m frantically trying to remember the difference between switching and shoppers won and lost whilst nodding along like I’ve got a clue.
One of them starts explaining their mammoth spreadsheet, and I’m thinking, “Christ, they could run circles around me with retail data analysis”.
Sound familiar?
If you’ve ever found yourself managing people who know way more than you do about the actual work, welcome to the club. It’s bloody terrifying at first, but here’s what I’ve learned: it’s also exactly where you need to be.
Why we tie ourselves in knots about it
Let’s get real about why this feels so uncomfortable. I used to think it was just me being rubbish, but after coaching dozens of women in similar positions, I know it’s much bigger than that.
We’re wired to think leaders should know everything. Most of us grew up watching controlling managers who seemed to have all the answers. The loudest voice in the room was usually the boss, right? So, when you’re suddenly managing a packaging technologist who’s forgotten more about materials than you’ll ever learn, it feels wrong.
The imposter feelings are real. That voice whispering “they’ll find out you don’t belong here” gets louder when you’re surrounded by expertise you don’t have. I spent months convinced my team would cotton on that I didn’t know the difference between AWOP and FOP (still learning, to be honest).
We confuse our job description. Somewhere along the way, we decide that being promoted means we should magically absorb everyone else’s knowledge. Spoiler alert: that’s not how it works, and trying will drive you mental.
What actually works instead
Here’s the thing nobody tells you: your job isn’t to be the smartest person in the room. It’s to be the person who makes the smart people around you brilliant at what they do.
Think of yourself less like the star player and more like the coach who spots what each person needs to perform at their best. You’re not there to know everything about polymer chemistry or supply chain logistics. You’re there to ask the right questions, clear the obstacles, and make sure everyone’s pulling in the same direction.
My five tips for leading expert teams
1. Just say when you don’t know something
Honestly, this was the hardest one for me. But the day I stopped pretending and started saying “I don’t know that – can you explain?” everything changed. Your team aren’t idiots. They can tell when you’re winging it, and it makes them lose confidence in your judgement on the things you do know.
2. Get obsessed with asking better questions
Instead of trying to have answers, get really good at asking questions that unlock other people’s thinking. “What’s your biggest concern with this approach?” “If budget wasn’t an issue, what would you do differently?” “What am I not asking that I should be?”
3. Be crystal clear about the ‘what’ and ‘why’, then get out of the way
Your job is to paint the picture: what does success look like, why does it matter, what are the constraints? Then step back and let the experts figure out how. Micromanaging the technical detail when it’s not your area is a mug’s game.
4. Pay attention to the stuff they can’t see
This is where your emotional intelligence becomes your superpower. You might not know the technicalities, but you can spot when someone’s struggling, when team dynamics are off, or when communication is breaking down. Those people skills matter more than you think.
5. Have their backs in public
There’s nothing more powerful than saying to a client or senior stakeholder, “Sarah’s our expert on this – she’ll walk you through it.” You’re not diminishing yourself; you’re amplifying their authority and showing everyone you’re secure enough to let others shine.
When it clicked for me
I remember coaching a brilliant woman (let’s call her Rachel) who’d been promoted from commercial director into overseeing R&D. Overnight, she found herself managing food technologists who could talk for hours about water activity levels, emulsification systems, and shelf-life validation protocols like it was everyday chat.
Rachel’s first instinct was to prove herself by trying to master every technical detail. She’d stay up late reading food science journals, interrupt development meetings with half-formed questions about pH levels and preservative systems and generally exhaust herself trying to match their deep technical knowledge.
Her R&D team started getting frustrated. They felt micromanaged and undervalued. Innovation actually slowed down because everyone was second-guessing themselves instead of just getting on with the science.
The breakthrough came when Rachel stopped trying to be the food technologist and started playing to her actual strengths. She was brilliant at understanding market opportunities, translating consumer needs into product briefs, and spotting commercial potential in technical developments. Meanwhile, she let her R&D team do what they did best – the complex formulation work and technical problem-solving.
Within a few months, the whole dynamic shifted. Her team felt trusted to use their expertise, Rachel felt confident in her strategic role, and – the best bit – they started collaborating naturally because everyone was playing to their strengths.
Try this in the next week
- In your next team meeting, ask one question instead of giving your opinion first
- When someone updates you on a project, resist the urge to dive into the how – stick to checking the what and when
- Before jumping in with your view, pause and ask, “What do you think?”
- Find one opportunity to publicly highlight someone else’s expertise
- Make a list of the areas where you don’t need to be the expert, then consciously let them go
The truth about leadership
If you’ve been promoted to manage people with more technical knowledge than you, it’s not because someone made a mistake. It’s because they saw something in your leadership ability that goes beyond technical expertise.
Your value isn’t in knowing everything – it’s in creating the conditions where everyone else’s knowledge can thrive. Stop trying to be the expert at everything and start being brilliant at the things only you can do: setting direction, removing obstacles, and helping your people be the best version of themselves.
That’s proper leadership, and it’s exactly what your team needs from you.
Looking for more straight-talking leadership tools? Listen to this episode of the Fearless Foodie podcast where I talk all about this with Danny Franklin.


Recent Comments